Hi Paulnick,
Welcome on our forum
The Midi desks (fader wings) that you mention are all good fader wings.
Every midi desk has its pros and cons, here are some from my point of view:
Akai APC40:
Pros
- Nice midi desk with a lot of playback buttons with a good clear status feedback of the Cuelists
- Faders to use with the playback faders.
Cons
- Small faders, so not very precise
- No speed controls for the Cuelists
- A lot of buttons that are not used by Cuelux
Elation Midicon:
Pros
- Perfect midi desk to use with Cuelux, it is a midi desk designed to do lighting
- Three encoder wheels for positioning moving lights, mixing RGB .....
- A lot of playback buttons
Cons
- No controls to change the speed of a cuelist
Behringer BCF2000:
Pros
- Motorized faders
- Speed controls
Cons
- uhhhhhh...
Also take a look at our
Youtube video about Midi devices, I have used a BCF2000 in that movie.
If I had to choose between the above I would go for the Behringer BCF2000, it is a nice small desk with a lot of usable functions.
Maybe there are a few other forum users who are willing to give their opinion on your question.
Regards,
Bart